C-WAYS source matching work - Revision history

Rebull at 21:11, 12 July 2012

2012-07-12T21:11:06Z

Rebull at 20:14, 6 July 2012

2012-07-06T20:14:34Z

Rebull at 20:12, 6 July 2012

2012-07-06T20:12:21Z

Mpiper at 16:37, 6 July 2012

2012-07-06T16:37:02Z

Mpiper at 16:34, 6 July 2012

2012-07-06T16:34:06Z

Barge: /* The mechanics of what we need to do */

2012-07-02T03:16:43Z

The mechanics of what we need to do

Barge: /* The mechanics of what we need to do */

2012-07-02T03:15:50Z

The mechanics of what we need to do

Barge: /* The mechanics of what we need to do */

2012-07-02T03:14:59Z

The mechanics of what we need to do

Barge at 03:14, 2 July 2012

2012-07-02T03:14:09Z

Barge: /* The mechanics of what we need to do */

2012-07-02T03:01:03Z

The mechanics of what we need to do

@@ Line 224: / Line 224: @@
 | BRC 27 only. antiquated coordinates.
 | have whole table from journal. done in center (see below). over whole region, LMR beat against 2mass in region and took nearest within 5(!!) arcsec. several still don't have matches. region we care about is small compared to region they worked on.
-| '''COORD NEED CHECKING AND POSSIBLY UPDATING.''' [[file:shevchenko_20120514.txt]] [[file:shevchenko_20120615.txt]] here is my file of the sources which has the published RA and Dec (B1950) and then a converted-to-J2000 version of the published coordinates, both written in two ways (degrees and hh:mm:ss, dd:mm:ss) and the proposed 2mass match (done blindly by the computer). if it has an asterisk (*) in front of the name, it is in the region we care about. Is it correctly matched to the right 2mass source? if not, what should it be??<BR>Waiting Debbie and Lauren source matching.<Br>[[File:Shevchenko_2012_06_27.xlsx]]<Br> The Shevchenko data had some very weird anomalies that bear further scrutiny by Luisa.  We concluded that maybe some numbers had been swapped on source #99, and there are several multiple sources that were listed as one source. <font color="green">NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR. Note also that there were several problems here, most likely because of version confusion, e.g., starting with 5/14 source list above, rather than 6/15 version. ''please be careful with catalog versions.''  NB: just YSOs tabulated</font>
+| '''COORD NEED CHECKING AND POSSIBLY UPDATING.''' [[file:shevchenko_20120514.txt]] [[file:shevchenko_20120615.txt]] here is my file of the sources which has the published RA and Dec (B1950) and then a converted-to-J2000 version of the published coordinates, both written in two ways (degrees and hh:mm:ss, dd:mm:ss) and the proposed 2mass match (done blindly by the computer). if it has an asterisk (*) in front of the name, it is in the region we care about. Is it correctly matched to the right 2mass source? if not, what should it be??<BR>Waiting Debbie and Lauren source matching.<Br>[[File:Shevchenko_2012_06_27.xlsx]]<Br> The Shevchenko data had some very weird anomalies that bear further scrutiny by Luisa.  We concluded that maybe some numbers had been swapped on source #99, and there are several multiple sources that were listed as one source. <font color="green">NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR. Note also that there were several problems here, most likely because of version confusion, e.g., starting with 5/14 source list above, rather than 6/15 version. ''please be careful with catalog versions.'' [[File:Shevchenko_2012_06_27_lmr.xlsx]] is my updated version of your xls.  NB: just YSOs tabulated</font>
 |-
 | Wiramihardja et al. 1986

@@ Line 180: / Line 180: @@
 | Getman et al 2007
 | X-rays. BRC 38 only. coordinates likely just fine.
-| got all tables from journal. LMR has merged t1,t2,t3 together. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12.
+| got all tables from journal. LMR has merged t1,t2,t3 together.
-|need to merge it to rest of catalogs.<BR> '''does it really have all of [http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/3-oktoskip/nisini01.pdf Nisini et al. (2001)] already in t3? - YES, ''' ''Getman Table 3 contains K, 2MASS and Spitzer data for all 20 ''Embedded Young objects'' from Nisini Table 2 <BR> Getman Tables 1 and 2 contain X-Ray and MIR data for Nisini stars 2, 3, 10, 11<BR>--Peggy Piper 20:56, 10 June 2012 (PDT)'' <br>NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR  NB: all sources detected are tabulated; the globule sources are the only ones clearly asserted as likely young, so i've just tagged those as YSOs.
+|need to merge it to rest of catalogs.<BR> '''does it really have all of [http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/3-oktoskip/nisini01.pdf Nisini et al. (2001)] already in t3? - YES, ''' ''Getman Table 3 contains K, 2MASS and Spitzer data for all 20 ''Embedded Young objects'' from Nisini Table 2 <BR> Getman Tables 1 and 2 contain X-Ray and MIR data for Nisini stars 2, 3, 10, 11<BR>--Peggy Piper 20:56, 10 June 2012 (PDT)'' <br> <font color="green">NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR  NB: all sources detected are tabulated; the globule sources are the only ones clearly asserted as likely young, so i've just tagged those as YSOs.</font>
 |-
 | Beltran et al. 2009
 | NIR. 38 only.  coordinates likely just fine.
 | got all tables from journal. ([http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/1-essential/beltran09data/ link])
-| <strike>need to merge relevant bits of tables together</strike>. individual tables have been merged together. still need to merge that to rest of catalogs. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: all sources detected are tabulated! text talks a lot about how there are YSOs there, but THERE IS NO TABLE OF JUST YSOs. Sigh. Merged photometry in but cannot of course tag the ones they think are young.
+| <strike>need to merge relevant bits of tables together</strike>. individual tables have been merged together. still need to merge that to rest of catalogs. <font color="green">NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: all sources detected are tabulated! text talks a lot about how there are YSOs there, but THERE IS NO TABLE OF JUST YSOs. Sigh. Merged photometry in but cannot of course tag the ones they think are young.</font>
 |-
 |Choudhury et al. 2010
 | MIR. 38 only. coordinates likely just fine.
 | got all tables from journal. ([http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/1-essential/choud10_data/ link])
-| <strike>need to merge relevant bits of tables together</strike> tables from paper have been merged together. still need to merge that to rest of catalogs. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR. NB: not entirely clear if all objects are being asserted as YSOs or not. Includes stuff in later table with a spectral type for an object that I can't find in Ogura (Ogura-BRC38-17). Merged photometry in but cannot of course tag the ones they think are young.
+| <strike>need to merge relevant bits of tables together</strike> tables from paper have been merged together. still need to merge that to rest of catalogs. <font color="green">NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR. NB: not entirely clear if all objects are being asserted as YSOs or not. Includes stuff in later table with a spectral type for an object that I can't find in Ogura (Ogura-BRC38-17). Merged photometry in but cannot of course tag the ones they think are young.</font>
 |-
 | Chauhan et al. 2009
 | NIR, MIR (IRAC only). 27 and 38. coordinates ... odd. look at carefully.
 | got all tables from journal. ([http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/1-essential/chauhan09data/ link])
-| need to merge their tables together (will take some care! - do this if the rest of the bold stuff here is done and you're chomping at the bit for more), then merge that to rest of catalogs. <BR>Chauhan table 6 has been merged with table 3.  Sources within .13 seconds for right ascension and 2 arcseconds for declination were considered matches (2 asec = ~.13 sec).  All 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 6 were much smaller than this.  Three 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 3 had slightly larger mismatch (0.15 and 0.17 sec mismatch).  Also checked 2MASS names against Ogura list and all are correct.  Origin/meaning of non matching? Megeath or Allen et al. 2004?  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged1.xls]]  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged1.txt]] NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: just YSOs tabulated, though for 27 there are indeed sources that appear in the IRAC table that do not appear in the JHK table.
+| need to merge their tables together (will take some care! - do this if the rest of the bold stuff here is done and you're chomping at the bit for more), then merge that to rest of catalogs. <BR>Chauhan table 6 has been merged with table 3.  Sources within .13 seconds for right ascension and 2 arcseconds for declination were considered matches (2 asec = ~.13 sec).  All 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 6 were much smaller than this.  Three 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 3 had slightly larger mismatch (0.15 and 0.17 sec mismatch).  Also checked 2MASS names against Ogura list and all are correct.  Origin/meaning of non matching? Megeath or Allen et al. 2004?  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged1.xls]]  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged1.txt]] <font color="green">NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: just YSOs tabulated, though for 27 there are indeed sources that appear in the IRAC table that do not appear in the JHK table.</font>
 |-
 | Barentsen et al. 2011
 | iprime,rprime, halpha. BRC 34, 38.
 | got all tables from journal.
-| LMR has already merged it to rest of catalogs. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: just YSOs tabulated
+| LMR has already merged it to rest of catalogs. <font color="green">NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: just YSOs tabulated</font>
 |-
 | Nakano et al. 2012
 | iprime, halpha, some AKARI. BRC 34, 38.
 | got all tables from journal. ([http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/1-essential/nakano12data/ link])
-| LMR has already merged it to rest of catalogs. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: just YSOs tabulated
+| LMR has already merged it to rest of catalogs. <font color="green">NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: just YSOs tabulated</font>
 |-
 | Ogura et al. 2002
 | BRC 27, 34, 38.  turns out will probably need 26 too!! '''there are finding charts!!!'''
 | 34 is ~done. 27 only done in center (see rebull et al 2012 below). 26, 38 not touched. [http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/1-essential/group%20S/ogura02data/ link] for data files as downloaded from journal
-| '''COORD NEED **UPDATING**'''  34 is done (see below). 27 is done only in center (see below). 26, 38 are not touched. need to obtain list of objects as published, find match in 2mass, assemble list of matches betw this and 2mass. you probably will need the finding charts in the paper to sort out the matches.<BR>Ogura list updated 20120625 (sorry, ignore the date in the name)<BR>text [[File:CWAYSBRC273438Oguraids_20120614.txt]]<BR>excel[[File:CWAYSBRC273438Oguraids_20120614.xls]]<BR>coordinates entered and matched, Peggy's groups cross checked within group, with Rebull 2012,and with Jackie's group. waiting Lauren and Jackie's groups cross check.  There were no sources for BRC 26. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: just YSOs tabulated
+| '''COORD NEED **UPDATING**'''  34 is done (see below). 27 is done only in center (see below). 26, 38 are not touched. need to obtain list of objects as published, find match in 2mass, assemble list of matches betw this and 2mass. you probably will need the finding charts in the paper to sort out the matches.<BR>Ogura list updated 20120625 (sorry, ignore the date in the name)<BR>text [[File:CWAYSBRC273438Oguraids_20120614.txt]]<BR>excel[[File:CWAYSBRC273438Oguraids_20120614.xls]]<BR>coordinates entered and matched, Peggy's groups cross checked within group, with Rebull 2012,and with Jackie's group. waiting Lauren and Jackie's groups cross check.  There were no sources for BRC 26. <font color="green">NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: just YSOs tabulated</font>
 |-
 | Gregorio-Hetem et al. 2009
@@ Line 219: / Line 219: @@
 [[File:SourceMatchingGregorio.xlsx‎]]
 [[File:SourceMatchingGregorio.txt‎]]
-NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.   NB: just YSOs tabulated
+<font color="green">NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.   NB: just YSOs tabulated</font>
 |-
 | Shevchenko et al. 1999
 | BRC 27 only. antiquated coordinates.
 | have whole table from journal. done in center (see below). over whole region, LMR beat against 2mass in region and took nearest within 5(!!) arcsec. several still don't have matches. region we care about is small compared to region they worked on.
-| '''COORD NEED CHECKING AND POSSIBLY UPDATING.''' [[file:shevchenko_20120514.txt]] [[file:shevchenko_20120615.txt]] here is my file of the sources which has the published RA and Dec (B1950) and then a converted-to-J2000 version of the published coordinates, both written in two ways (degrees and hh:mm:ss, dd:mm:ss) and the proposed 2mass match (done blindly by the computer). if it has an asterisk (*) in front of the name, it is in the region we care about. Is it correctly matched to the right 2mass source? if not, what should it be??<BR>Waiting Debbie and Lauren source matching.<Br>[[File:Shevchenko_2012_06_27.xlsx]]<Br> The Shevchenko data had some very weird anomalies that bear further scrutiny by Luisa.  We concluded that maybe some numbers had been swapped on source #99, and there are several multiple sources that were listed as one source. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR. Note also that there were several problems here, most likely because of version confusion, e.g., starting with 5/14 source list above, rather than 6/15 version. ''please be careful with catalog versions.''  NB: just YSOs tabulated
+| '''COORD NEED CHECKING AND POSSIBLY UPDATING.''' [[file:shevchenko_20120514.txt]] [[file:shevchenko_20120615.txt]] here is my file of the sources which has the published RA and Dec (B1950) and then a converted-to-J2000 version of the published coordinates, both written in two ways (degrees and hh:mm:ss, dd:mm:ss) and the proposed 2mass match (done blindly by the computer). if it has an asterisk (*) in front of the name, it is in the region we care about. Is it correctly matched to the right 2mass source? if not, what should it be??<BR>Waiting Debbie and Lauren source matching.<Br>[[File:Shevchenko_2012_06_27.xlsx]]<Br> The Shevchenko data had some very weird anomalies that bear further scrutiny by Luisa.  We concluded that maybe some numbers had been swapped on source #99, and there are several multiple sources that were listed as one source. <font color="green">NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR. Note also that there were several problems here, most likely because of version confusion, e.g., starting with 5/14 source list above, rather than 6/15 version. ''please be careful with catalog versions.''  NB: just YSOs tabulated</font>
 |-
 | Wiramihardja et al. 1986
 | BRC 27 only. antiquated coordinates.
 | have nothing from journal (it's too old).
-|need to merge it to rest of catalogs.<BR> '''<strike>COORD NEED **UPDATING**</strike>''' done in center (see below). need to obtain list of objects as published, find match in 2mass, assemble list of matches betw this and 2mass. NB: region we care about is probably smaller than region they published. no need to find matches for objects outside of our region but may be easier to just blow through and do all of them?<BR> '''DONE''' coordinates entered, matched and data entered, Bob and Peggy's groups cross checked.<BR>text[[File:CWAYSBRC27Wiramihardjaidsdata_20120614.txt]] excel[[File:CWAYSBRC27Wiramihardjaidsdata_20120614.xls]]  NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR. NB: just YSOs tabulated
+|need to merge it to rest of catalogs.<BR> '''<strike>COORD NEED **UPDATING**</strike>''' done in center (see below). need to obtain list of objects as published, find match in 2mass, assemble list of matches betw this and 2mass. NB: region we care about is probably smaller than region they published. no need to find matches for objects outside of our region but may be easier to just blow through and do all of them?<BR> '''DONE''' coordinates entered, matched and data entered, Bob and Peggy's groups cross checked.<BR>text[[File:CWAYSBRC27Wiramihardjaidsdata_20120614.txt]] excel[[File:CWAYSBRC27Wiramihardjaidsdata_20120614.xls]]  <font color="green">NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR. NB: just YSOs tabulated</font>
 |-
 | Rebull et al. 2012
 | BRC 27, 34 only. coordinates and crossmatches to literature should be good. I hope!!
 | have tables, of course!
-| should hopefully be ok! [[file:rebull2012t1brcxids_20120514.txt]] -- file of all literature information, crossids. note that technically this is in latex format, so "&" divides columns and \nodata means, well, "no data".  some people provided errors, some didn't, so that is reflected in this table.  last object listed for BRC 27 is actually off the edge of the IRAC 4-band region, and no longer appears in the table. The cross-ids should actually be ok, though. [[file:rebull2012t2_20120518.txt]] -- file of new measurements discussed in Rebull et al. 2012.  Note that there are both limits and errors in this table.  NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.   NB: just YSOs tabulated in the PAPER, but because I have access to the full catalogs we worked with, I've merged the full catalogs into our full catalogs.
+| should hopefully be ok! [[file:rebull2012t1brcxids_20120514.txt]] -- file of all literature information, crossids. note that technically this is in latex format, so "&" divides columns and \nodata means, well, "no data".  some people provided errors, some didn't, so that is reflected in this table.  last object listed for BRC 27 is actually off the edge of the IRAC 4-band region, and no longer appears in the table. The cross-ids should actually be ok, though. [[file:rebull2012t2_20120518.txt]] -- file of new measurements discussed in Rebull et al. 2012.  Note that there are both limits and errors in this table.  <font color="green">NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.   NB: just YSOs tabulated in the PAPER, but because I have access to the full catalogs we worked with, I've merged the full catalogs into our full catalogs.</font>
 |}

@@ Line 180: / Line 180: @@
 | Getman et al 2007
 | X-rays. BRC 38 only. coordinates likely just fine.
-| got all tables from journal. LMR has merged t1,t2,t3 together
+| got all tables from journal. LMR has merged t1,t2,t3 together. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12.
-|need to merge it to rest of catalogs.<BR> '''does it really have all of [http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/3-oktoskip/nisini01.pdf Nisini et al. (2001)] already in t3? - YES, ''' ''Getman Table 3 contains K, 2MASS and Spitzer data for all 20 ''Embedded Young objects'' from Nisini Table 2 <BR> Getman Tables 1 and 2 contain X-Ray and MIR data for Nisini stars 2, 3, 10, 11<BR>--Peggy Piper 20:56, 10 June 2012 (PDT)''
+|need to merge it to rest of catalogs.<BR> '''does it really have all of [http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/3-oktoskip/nisini01.pdf Nisini et al. (2001)] already in t3? - YES, ''' ''Getman Table 3 contains K, 2MASS and Spitzer data for all 20 ''Embedded Young objects'' from Nisini Table 2 <BR> Getman Tables 1 and 2 contain X-Ray and MIR data for Nisini stars 2, 3, 10, 11<BR>--Peggy Piper 20:56, 10 June 2012 (PDT)'' <br>NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR  NB: all sources detected are tabulated; the globule sources are the only ones clearly asserted as likely young, so i've just tagged those as YSOs.
 |-
 | Beltran et al. 2009
 | NIR. 38 only.  coordinates likely just fine.
 | got all tables from journal. ([http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/1-essential/beltran09data/ link])
-| <strike>need to merge relevant bits of tables together</strike>. individual tables have been merged together. still need to merge that to rest of catalogs.
+| <strike>need to merge relevant bits of tables together</strike>. individual tables have been merged together. still need to merge that to rest of catalogs. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: all sources detected are tabulated! text talks a lot about how there are YSOs there, but THERE IS NO TABLE OF JUST YSOs. Sigh. Merged photometry in but cannot of course tag the ones they think are young.
 |-
 |Choudhury et al. 2010
 | MIR. 38 only. coordinates likely just fine.
 | got all tables from journal. ([http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/1-essential/choud10_data/ link])
-| <strike>need to merge relevant bits of tables together</strike> tables from paper have been merged together. still need to merge that to rest of catalogs.
+| <strike>need to merge relevant bits of tables together</strike> tables from paper have been merged together. still need to merge that to rest of catalogs. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR. NB: not entirely clear if all objects are being asserted as YSOs or not. Includes stuff in later table with a spectral type for an object that I can't find in Ogura (Ogura-BRC38-17). Merged photometry in but cannot of course tag the ones they think are young.
 |-
 | Chauhan et al. 2009
 | NIR, MIR (IRAC only). 27 and 38. coordinates ... odd. look at carefully.
 | got all tables from journal. ([http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/1-essential/chauhan09data/ link])
-| need to merge their tables together (will take some care! - do this if the rest of the bold stuff here is done and you're chomping at the bit for more), then merge that to rest of catalogs. <BR>Chauhan table 6 has been merged with table 3.  Sources within .13 seconds for right ascension and 2 arcseconds for declination were considered matches (2 asec = ~.13 sec).  All 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 6 were much smaller than this.  Three 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 3 had slightly larger mismatch (0.15 and 0.17 sec mismatch).  Also checked 2MASS names against Ogura list and all are correct.  Origin/meaning of non matching? Megeath or Allen et al. 2004?  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged1.xls]]  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged1.txt]]
+| need to merge their tables together (will take some care! - do this if the rest of the bold stuff here is done and you're chomping at the bit for more), then merge that to rest of catalogs. <BR>Chauhan table 6 has been merged with table 3.  Sources within .13 seconds for right ascension and 2 arcseconds for declination were considered matches (2 asec = ~.13 sec).  All 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 6 were much smaller than this.  Three 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 3 had slightly larger mismatch (0.15 and 0.17 sec mismatch).  Also checked 2MASS names against Ogura list and all are correct.  Origin/meaning of non matching? Megeath or Allen et al. 2004?  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged1.xls]]  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged1.txt]] NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: just YSOs tabulated, though for 27 there are indeed sources that appear in the IRAC table that do not appear in the JHK table.
 |-
 | Barentsen et al. 2011
 | iprime,rprime, halpha. BRC 34, 38.
 | got all tables from journal.
-| LMR has already merged it to rest of catalogs.
+| LMR has already merged it to rest of catalogs. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: just YSOs tabulated
 |-
 | Nakano et al. 2012
 | iprime, halpha, some AKARI. BRC 34, 38.
 | got all tables from journal. ([http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/1-essential/nakano12data/ link])
-| LMR has already merged it to rest of catalogs.
+| LMR has already merged it to rest of catalogs. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: just YSOs tabulated
 |-
 | Ogura et al. 2002
 | BRC 27, 34, 38.  turns out will probably need 26 too!! '''there are finding charts!!!'''
 | 34 is ~done. 27 only done in center (see rebull et al 2012 below). 26, 38 not touched. [http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/1-essential/group%20S/ogura02data/ link] for data files as downloaded from journal
-| '''COORD NEED **UPDATING**'''  34 is done (see below). 27 is done only in center (see below). 26, 38 are not touched. need to obtain list of objects as published, find match in 2mass, assemble list of matches betw this and 2mass. you probably will need the finding charts in the paper to sort out the matches.<BR>Ogura list updated 20120625 (sorry, ignore the date in the name)<BR>text [[File:CWAYSBRC273438Oguraids_20120614.txt]]<BR>excel[[File:CWAYSBRC273438Oguraids_20120614.xls]]<BR>coordinates entered and matched, Peggy's groups cross checked within group, with Rebull 2012,and with Jackie's group. waiting Lauren and Jackie's groups cross check.  There were no sources for BRC 26.
+| '''COORD NEED **UPDATING**'''  34 is done (see below). 27 is done only in center (see below). 26, 38 are not touched. need to obtain list of objects as published, find match in 2mass, assemble list of matches betw this and 2mass. you probably will need the finding charts in the paper to sort out the matches.<BR>Ogura list updated 20120625 (sorry, ignore the date in the name)<BR>text [[File:CWAYSBRC273438Oguraids_20120614.txt]]<BR>excel[[File:CWAYSBRC273438Oguraids_20120614.xls]]<BR>coordinates entered and matched, Peggy's groups cross checked within group, with Rebull 2012,and with Jackie's group. waiting Lauren and Jackie's groups cross check.  There were no sources for BRC 26. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.  NB: just YSOs tabulated
 |-
 | Gregorio-Hetem et al. 2009
@@ Line 217: / Line 217: @@
 | have whole tables from journal ([http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/2-scanfordata/gregoriodata/ link]). merged together. done in center (see below). over whole region, LMR beat against 2mass in region and took nearest within 2 arcsec. several still don't have matches. region we care about is small compared to region they worked on.
 | '''COORD NEED CHECKING AND POSSIBLY UPDATING.''' [[file:gregorio_20120514.txt]] here is my file of the sources which has the published RA and Dec written in two ways (both J2000) and the proposed 2mass match (done blindly by the computer). if it has an asterisk (*) in front of the name, it is in the region we care about. Is it correctly matched to the right 2mass source? if not, what should it be??<BR> Jackie and Bob source matching.
-[[File:SourceMatchingGregorio.xlsx‎]] <br>
+[[File:SourceMatchingGregorio.xlsx‎]]
 [[File:SourceMatchingGregorio.txt‎]]
 |-
 | Shevchenko et al. 1999
 | BRC 27 only. antiquated coordinates.
 | have whole table from journal. done in center (see below). over whole region, LMR beat against 2mass in region and took nearest within 5(!!) arcsec. several still don't have matches. region we care about is small compared to region they worked on.
-| '''COORD NEED CHECKING AND POSSIBLY UPDATING.''' [[file:shevchenko_20120514.txt]] [[file:shevchenko_20120615.txt]] here is my file of the sources which has the published RA and Dec (B1950) and then a converted-to-J2000 version of the published coordinates, both written in two ways (degrees and hh:mm:ss, dd:mm:ss) and the proposed 2mass match (done blindly by the computer). if it has an asterisk (*) in front of the name, it is in the region we care about. Is it correctly matched to the right 2mass source? if not, what should it be??<BR>Waiting Debbie and Lauren source matching.<Br>[[File:Shevchenko_2012_06_27.xlsx]]<Br> The Shevchenko data had some very weird anomalies that bear further scrutiny by Luisa.  We concluded that maybe some numbers had been swapped on source #99, and there are several multiple sources that were listed as one source.
+| '''COORD NEED CHECKING AND POSSIBLY UPDATING.''' [[file:shevchenko_20120514.txt]] [[file:shevchenko_20120615.txt]] here is my file of the sources which has the published RA and Dec (B1950) and then a converted-to-J2000 version of the published coordinates, both written in two ways (degrees and hh:mm:ss, dd:mm:ss) and the proposed 2mass match (done blindly by the computer). if it has an asterisk (*) in front of the name, it is in the region we care about. Is it correctly matched to the right 2mass source? if not, what should it be??<BR>Waiting Debbie and Lauren source matching.<Br>[[File:Shevchenko_2012_06_27.xlsx]]<Br> The Shevchenko data had some very weird anomalies that bear further scrutiny by Luisa.  We concluded that maybe some numbers had been swapped on source #99, and there are several multiple sources that were listed as one source. NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR. Note also that there were several problems here, most likely because of version confusion, e.g., starting with 5/14 source list above, rather than 6/15 version. ''please be careful with catalog versions.''  NB: just YSOs tabulated
 |-
 | Wiramihardja et al. 1986
 | BRC 27 only. antiquated coordinates.
 | have nothing from journal (it's too old).
-|need to merge it to rest of catalogs.<BR> '''<strike>COORD NEED **UPDATING**</strike>''' done in center (see below). need to obtain list of objects as published, find match in 2mass, assemble list of matches betw this and 2mass. NB: region we care about is probably smaller than region they published. no need to find matches for objects outside of our region but may be easier to just blow through and do all of them?<BR> '''DONE''' coordinates entered, matched and data entered, Bob and Peggy's groups cross checked.<BR>text[[File:CWAYSBRC27Wiramihardjaidsdata_20120614.txt]]<BR>excel[[File:CWAYSBRC27Wiramihardjaidsdata_20120614.xls]]
+|need to merge it to rest of catalogs.<BR> '''<strike>COORD NEED **UPDATING**</strike>''' done in center (see below). need to obtain list of objects as published, find match in 2mass, assemble list of matches betw this and 2mass. NB: region we care about is probably smaller than region they published. no need to find matches for objects outside of our region but may be easier to just blow through and do all of them?<BR> '''DONE''' coordinates entered, matched and data entered, Bob and Peggy's groups cross checked.<BR>text[[File:CWAYSBRC27Wiramihardjaidsdata_20120614.txt]] excel[[File:CWAYSBRC27Wiramihardjaidsdata_20120614.xls]]  NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR. NB: just YSOs tabulated
 |-
 | Rebull et al. 2012
 | BRC 27, 34 only. coordinates and crossmatches to literature should be good. I hope!!
 | have tables, of course!
-| should hopefully be ok! [[file:rebull2012t1brcxids_20120514.txt]] -- file of all literature information, crossids. note that technically this is in latex format, so "&" divides columns and \nodata means, well, "no data".  some people provided errors, some didn't, so that is reflected in this table.  last object listed for BRC 27 is actually off the edge of the IRAC 4-band region, and no longer appears in the table. The cross-ids should actually be ok, though. [[file:rebull2012t2_20120518.txt]] -- file of new measurements discussed in Rebull et al. 2012.  Note that there are both limits and errors in this table.
+| should hopefully be ok! [[file:rebull2012t1brcxids_20120514.txt]] -- file of all literature information, crossids. note that technically this is in latex format, so "&" divides columns and \nodata means, well, "no data".  some people provided errors, some didn't, so that is reflected in this table.  last object listed for BRC 27 is actually off the edge of the IRAC 4-band region, and no longer appears in the table. The cross-ids should actually be ok, though. [[file:rebull2012t2_20120518.txt]] -- file of new measurements discussed in Rebull et al. 2012.  Note that there are both limits and errors in this table.  NOW MERGED INTO BIG ARRAY-7/3/12 --LMR.   NB: just YSOs tabulated in the PAPER, but because I have access to the full catalogs we worked with, I've merged the full catalogs into our full catalogs.
 |}

@@ Line 196: / Line 196: @@
 | NIR, MIR (IRAC only). 27 and 38. coordinates ... odd. look at carefully.
 | got all tables from journal. ([http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/1-essential/chauhan09data/ link])
-| need to merge their tables together (will take some care! - do this if the rest of the bold stuff here is done and you're chomping at the bit for more), then merge that to rest of catalogs. <BR>Chauhan table 6 has been merged with table 3.  Sources within .13 seconds for right ascension and 2 arcseconds for declination were considered matches (2 asec = ~.13 sec).  All 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 6 were much smaller than this.  Three 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 3 had slightly larger mismatch (0.15 and 0.17 sec mismatch).  Also checked 2MASS names against Ogura list and all are correct.  Origin/meaning of non matching? Megeath or Allen et al. 2004?  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged1.xls]]  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged.txt]]
+| need to merge their tables together (will take some care! - do this if the rest of the bold stuff here is done and you're chomping at the bit for more), then merge that to rest of catalogs. <BR>Chauhan table 6 has been merged with table 3.  Sources within .13 seconds for right ascension and 2 arcseconds for declination were considered matches (2 asec = ~.13 sec).  All 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 6 were much smaller than this.  Three 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 3 had slightly larger mismatch (0.15 and 0.17 sec mismatch).  Also checked 2MASS names against Ogura list and all are correct.  Origin/meaning of non matching? Megeath or Allen et al. 2004?  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged1.xls]]  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged1.txt]]
 |-
 | Barentsen et al. 2011

@@ Line 196: / Line 196: @@
 | NIR, MIR (IRAC only). 27 and 38. coordinates ... odd. look at carefully.
 | got all tables from journal. ([http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/1-essential/chauhan09data/ link])
-| need to merge their tables together (will take some care! - do this if the rest of the bold stuff here is done and you're chomping at the bit for more), then merge that to rest of catalogs. <BR>Chauhan table 6 has been merged with table 3.  Sources within .13 seconds for right ascension and 2 arcseconds for declination were considered matches (2 asec = ~.13 sec).  All 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 6 were much smaller than this.  Three 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 3 had slightly larger mismatch (0.15 and 0.17 sec mismatch).  Also checked 2MASS names against Ogura list and all are correct.  Origin/meaning of non matching? Megeath or Allen et al. 2004?  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged.xls]]  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged.txt]]
+| need to merge their tables together (will take some care! - do this if the rest of the bold stuff here is done and you're chomping at the bit for more), then merge that to rest of catalogs. <BR>Chauhan table 6 has been merged with table 3.  Sources within .13 seconds for right ascension and 2 arcseconds for declination were considered matches (2 asec = ~.13 sec).  All 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 6 were much smaller than this.  Three 2MASS table 3 to ra/dec table 3 had slightly larger mismatch (0.15 and 0.17 sec mismatch).  Also checked 2MASS names against Ogura list and all are correct.  Origin/meaning of non matching? Megeath or Allen et al. 2004?  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged1.xls]]  [[Media:ChauhanTableMerged.txt]]
 |-
 | Barentsen et al. 2011

@@ Line 216: / Line 216: @@
 | BRC 27 only. X-rays. coordinates probably ok.
 | have whole tables from journal ([http://web.ipac.caltech.edu/staff/rebull/working/cwayspapers/2-scanfordata/gregoriodata/ link]). merged together. done in center (see below). over whole region, LMR beat against 2mass in region and took nearest within 2 arcsec. several still don't have matches. region we care about is small compared to region they worked on.
-| '''COORD NEED CHECKING AND POSSIBLY UPDATING.''' [[file:gregorio_20120514.txt]] here is my file of the sources which has the published RA and Dec written in two ways (both J2000) and the proposed 2mass match (done blindly by the computer). if it has an asterisk (*) in front of the name, it is in the region we care about. Is it correctly matched to the right 2mass source? if not, what should it be??<BR>Waiting Jackie and Bob source matching.
+| '''COORD NEED CHECKING AND POSSIBLY UPDATING.''' [[file:gregorio_20120514.txt]] here is my file of the sources which has the published RA and Dec written in two ways (both J2000) and the proposed 2mass match (done blindly by the computer). if it has an asterisk (*) in front of the name, it is in the region we care about. Is it correctly matched to the right 2mass source? if not, what should it be??<BR> Jackie and Bob source matching. [[File:SourceMatchingGregorio.xlsx‎]]
 |-
 | Shevchenko et al. 1999